Help
Returns & refunds
Last updated November 17, 2026
30-day returns
You may request a return within 30 days of the date your order was delivered. Items must be unused, in their original packaging, with any seals, cards and accessories included. Opened blister packs and built LEGO sets can't be returned unless they arrived damaged or faulty.
10% handling fee
Approved returns are refunded less a 10% handling fee on the item price, which covers inspection, repacking and payment processing. For example, returning a $40.00 item refunds $36.00.
The handling fee is waived when an item arrives damaged, faulty, or isn't what you ordered. In those cases we also refund your original shipping cost.
How to start a return
- Contact us or email support@toystorey.store with your order number (it starts with TS-) and the item you'd like to return.
- We'll reply within 2 business days with return instructions and the return address.
- Pack the item securely and send it back. Return shipping is paid by you unless the item was damaged, faulty or incorrect.
When you'll get your money
Once your return arrives and passes inspection, we issue the refund within 5 business days. It goes back to your original payment method; your bank may take a further 5–10 days to show it.
Our orders are processed by our online reseller Paddle.com, which is the Merchant of Record. You can also find your purchase and request help at paddle.net using the email address you used at checkout.
Damaged in transit
Every order ships insured. If your parcel arrives damaged, please photograph the box and the item and send the photos to us within 7 days of delivery so we can arrange a replacement or full refund.